wow! really nice!

Excellently!

+7/7

Wow, so many great details! Good decision on the texture and colour. Great combosition and the lighting is much more dramatic than Revenge. I love these mysterious long shadows, and the little spider's a nice touch... like a silent witness of the event.

The only thing is that some of the bump maps used on various places are a bit profound and make the picture looks a bit busy. Also maybe a little more specularity can be used on the knife and pins on the doll, since right now the specular light on these glass sirfaces are drawing away the attention.... Just my own opinions. We'll never know if these suggestions work unless do some experiments and compare the results.

Overall it's a great concept and executed nicely. Really impressive work. +9 from me

Thanks for your comments, peoples.

Amoeba, You're not the only one who's made that observation. The problem is, the noise is fractal noise, dust, from aging the scene, which would naturally occur over time. Compare it to the original, which had no dust at all. I wonder if I can get away with removing the dust from the papers so they can be read without making the aging look inconsistent. And I agree with you about critiques; I've incorporated a lot of people's suggestions into this version which--I believe--has improved it a lot. Thanks for your input; I really do appreciate it.

wow. ia can't see nothing wrong in this pic...its wonderful, one of the best 3d models i've seen here...original,unusual,...i really like this image...what a creativity...millions of interpretations behind this scene...Its incredible that you isnt a elite member!!! my maximum score!

i'm not much for 3d but this is really great

this is a much better version!

Wonderful picture. Wonderful colors and textures. Great work.

i love the blood stained heart, very creative any chance of a closer look at this one? i like the composition better than revenge, I have just noticed it actually fits in to the golden ratio quite nicely, you can draw a spiral the sweeps through many of the features ending up nicly in the dolls head, which is probebly why my eye is so well guided round the image +5 from me

wow....i like this one a lot better than the other. it's darker and more dramatic. great job at revamping it. the other one looked like a childrens horror scene, this one is more adult...with a doll great job

I like this one much more than the first one.
The mood in it, is really well transcribed, and the mappings are fine.
If you can try to re-model the doll as an old bited-by-dog one, it should make a greater image, much more complete, with a real unity in it.
Great job, girl. +4/5

nice,like ant- i'd like to explore the scene a little more .stuff like the thumb print on the glass in" revenge" excite me. i've seen a lot of technically gifted work on this site( as is your work) but you have the soul of an artist. those of you who haven't checked out marcia 's other work really should!!!!!!!

The changes you have made vere preetty nice

awesome.. I love it

This is really great, great textures, a wonderful expression of the theme.

very well done, I love how this one is darker than the first, love your work +9

Nice colors and textures. Great work.

amazing work, wow! nice details and concept! full markS

There's nothing to complain about. Perfect.